Proceedings in the ongoing Sky Train trial took an unexpected turn on Monday when counsel for the first accused person (A1), Mrs. Victoria Barth, announced her withdrawal from the case in open court after the court declined a request to adjourn proceedings.
The development occurred after Mrs. Barth informed the court that several applications relating to the case were pending before both the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court.
According to her, the defence had filed an application invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court seeking an order of certiorari to quash the High Court’s orders of October 29, 2026, directing the first accused to testify. She told the court that the application, filed on November 11, 2026, had a return date of November 24.
She further indicated that a motion seeking to suspend the High Court’s orders pending the determination of the certiorari application had also been filed, with the same return date. In addition, she disclosed that a fresh application for stay of proceedings had been lodged at the Court of Appeal on November 12, with a return date of November 23.
Mrs. Barth argued that compelling the first accused to testify before the determination of those applications could render the appellate processes ineffective and deprive the superior courts of the opportunity to exercise their jurisdiction.
The prosecution, represented by Deputy Attorney-General Dr. Justice Srem-Sai, opposed the application, describing it as an abuse of court process intended to delay proceedings and prevent the first accused from entering the witness box.
He argued that the defence was pursuing multiple applications in different courts solely to frustrate the trial and noted that the mere filing of such applications did not automatically prevent the High Court from proceeding with the case.
Dr. Srem-Sai further cited legal authorities to support his position, contending that there was no order from a superior court restraining the trial court from continuing with the proceedings.
Responding, Mrs. Barth maintained that there was a legal distinction between applications brought under appellate jurisdiction and those filed under the Supreme Court’s supervisory jurisdiction, insisting that the pending applications warranted the court’s consideration.
In its ruling, the court stated that it had not received formal notice of the applications referenced by defence counsel and observed that, in any case, the filing of such applications did not automatically prevent the court from carrying on with its scheduled proceedings.
The court consequently indicated its intention to proceed with the hearing and directed that the first accused open his defence.
Following the ruling, Mrs. Barth announced her withdrawal from representing the first accused, stating that she was unable to comply with an order she believed infringed upon her client’s constitutional rights and could undermine processes she had initiated before the appellate courts.
The prosecution challenged the withdrawal, arguing that the procedures governing the withdrawal of legal representation in criminal matters had not been followed and describing the move as an attempt to achieve indirectly what the defence had failed to secure through formal applications.
After hearing submissions from both sides, the court granted the first accused one week to secure new legal representation of his choice.
The case has consequently been adjourned to Monday, November 23, 2026, for the continuation of proceedings.

